Saratoga Springs Office
100 West Avenue, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866Phone: (518) 581-8441
Reported in vol. 33, no. 10 criticizing an ALJ’s analysis and revealed an all too common misunderstanding of mental illness, “The very nature of bipolar disorder is that people with the disease experience fluctuations in their symptoms, so any single notation that a patient is feeling better or has had a ‘good day’ does not imply that the condition has been treated.”
cited: Scott v Astrue, 647 F.3d 734 (7th Cir. 2011)
In a case the district court found that an ALJ and fined the claimant not credible for failing to follow prescribe mental health treatment. The court criticized the ALJ’s finding and rejected the medical complaints because mental illness is an unreported condition. Cited Regennitter v Comm’r 166 F. 3d 1294, 1299-1300 (9th Cir. 1999), “it is a questionable practice to chastise one with a mental impairment for the exercise of poor judgment in seeking rehabilitation.”
Cited: August 2011 NOSSCR vol. 33 no. 8
In the case Williams v Astrue the Northern District of Indiana reversed the administrative law judges hearing where the plaintiff had morbid obesity as a severe impairment and the district court considered the other impairments that the claimant had. The claimant also suffered from a combination of bilateral knee impairments. The court essentially said you have to take a combination of impairments as a whole in order to assess disability determination.
The Law Firm Rodriguez & Doern is now accessing Social Security Disability Claimant’s records online by electronic records express. This is a secure online system where you can access the records that are being kept in the Office of Disability Appeals for review electronically over the internet. This should give more prompt information to the law firm to better assist our clients.
-James E. D. Doern
Administrative law judge in a social security case cannot reject a treating physicians opinion without providing reason that are “as comprehensible and analytical as feasible, and must provide the factual foundation for his decision and the specific findings that were rejected.” In this particular case there were several opinions rendered from treating sources of the poor emotional health of the claimant. At Rodriguez & Doern it is our recommendation that the claimants get whatever possible opinion testimonials from their treating physicians supported by the medical records which should be given controlling weight at the hearing. It significantly improves the claimant’s chance of being successful at a hearing if the treating physician supports the disability claim.
-James E. D. Doern, Esq.
cited: NOSCCR vol.32, no. 9 - September 2010
The 11th circuit has ruled recently in a case reported in the National Organization of Social Security Claimants’ Representative (NOSSCR) newsletter. That administrative law judge in a social security case cannot reject a treating physician’s opinion in a Fibromyalgia case based upon on lack of clinical findings. In a Fibromyalgia case a claimants subjective complaints of pain “are often the only means of determining the severity of patient’s conditions and the functional limitations cause thereby.” The court apparently understood that Fibromyalgia is extremely debilitating and the pain is a subjective determination by the patient.
-James E. Doern
(518) 581-8441Monday - Friday: 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
I was treated always in a courteous and professional, respectful manner. Jim Doern helped me to the best of his ability and I was extremely satisfied.
The Business Review – September 22, 2008 “Reforms shift bankruptcy filings towards chapter 13